Exotic Pets and Unusual Pets for Sale

If you’re wondering where to buy a Chinchilla, or you’re considering a pet Tarantula, Uncle Bill’s is the place for you! We have the best selection of unusual and exotic pets and supplies for sale in Central Indiana, and all of our animals are ethically sourced.

Uncle Bill’s associates are happy to answer any questions you may have about unusual pets and exotic pets. Our associates are well-trained and happy to help you find the right pet. We have the answers you need about Hedgehog care, the temperaments of Land Hermit Crabs, and beyond.

Choosing an Exotic Pet

Some exotic pets are easy to care for while other exotic pets for sale require large enclosures, special diets, and several hours of human interaction every day. We can help you choose an exotic or unusual pet that works for your lifestyle based on:

  • Temperament – If you’re looking for a pet you can hold, Sugar Gliders would be a better choice than an Emperor Scorpion. While Scorpions are fascinating animals, they aren’t exactly cuddly.

  • Care requirements – All of our exotic animals require more than just food and water. Some animals need a specific type of lighting, heat, and humidity. Some pets should be kept in pairs, and some require a dietary mix of insects, fruits, vegetables, and pre-packaged foods.

  • Budget – Some exotic animals for sale may initially seem costly (because of the expense of setting up the enclosure), but some of these animals have low ongoing food and care costs.
We are proud to offer a wide range of exotic and unusual pets in Indiana. Our incredible animals include:
  • Chinchillas
  • Tarantulas
  • Hermit Crabs
  • Isopods
  • Hedgehogs
  • Jumping Spiders
  • And more!

    Our unusual and exotic pets for sale are so unique that some are hard to keep year-round, so always call ahead if you’re looking for a specific species.

Exotic Pet Supplies

Uncle Bill’s carries a broad selection of high-quality exotic animal supplies – Chinchilla food, Ferret litter, Hermit Crab sand, and more. We update our online and in-store inventory regularly. Please call or visit an Uncle Bill’s store near you if you have questions about exotic pet supplies. 

uncle bills tarantula exotic pets
Get news about special offers, sales, contests, and more – sign up for our monthly newsletter!

Uncle Bill’s Pet Center is an ethical, humane source for a wide variety of pets, including Dogs, Cats, Fish, Birds, Rabbits, Guinea Pigs, Reptiles, Amphibians, and other small and exotic animals. We are the premier pet store in the Indianapolis area, with locations on the east, northeast, and west sides of Indianapolis, as well as in Fishers, Greenwood, and Ft. Wayne. Uncle Bill’s Pet Center carries a large inventory of pet supplies, and is committed to helping our customers understand and care for their animals throughout their lives.